“Papa What If” is one of those songs that sneaks into your heart with its sweet, simple charm. Sung by Bobby Bare alongside his young son, Bobby Bare Jr., it’s more than just a song—it’s a tender conversation between a father and child, filled with curiosity, imagination, and love. Released in 1973 as part of Bobby Bare’s album Singin’ in the Kitchen, the song captures the unfiltered wonder of a child’s mind paired with the steady wisdom of a parent.
The lyrics take the form of a child asking whimsical questions—like what would happen if the sun stopped shining or if fish grew legs—and a father responding with warmth and patience. It’s these heartfelt exchanges that make the song feel so personal, like you’re eavesdropping on a moment of pure familial love.
Set to a simple melody, the arrangement complements the conversational style of the lyrics. Bare’s rich, calming voice contrasts beautifully with the innocent, slightly off-key musings of his son. Together, they weave a narrative that feels both timeless and deeply relatable—reminding listeners of the innocence of childhood and the bond between generations.
This song isn’t just a recording; it’s a memory. It’s the kind of piece that makes you think of your own family, of those quiet, meaningful moments that shape who you are. Whether you’re listening as a parent, a child, or someone nostalgic for simpler days, “Papa What If” feels like a warm hug for your soul
Video