Introduction
Growing up in a small town, I remember my father strumming his guitar on the porch, the twang of country music filling the evening air. One song that always stood out was Randy Travis’ On the Other Hand. Its heartfelt lyrics and gentle melody seemed to tell a story of love and choice that resonated deeply, even in my young mind. Years later, I learned the song’s journey from a minor hit to a chart-topping classic, a testament to its timeless appeal and the vision of its creators, Paul Overstreet and Don Schlitz.
About The Composition
- Title: On the Other Hand
- Composer: Paul Overstreet and Don Schlitz
- Premiere Date: July 1985 (initial release); April 1986 (re-release)
- Album/Opus/Collection: Storms of Life (1986)
- Genre: Country, Traditional Country
Background
On the Other Hand was born during a songwriting session between Paul Overstreet and Don Schlitz, two prolific figures in country music. According to the Wikipedia entry, the song’s concept emerged when the duo struggled with another piece titled Greedy Heart. Schlitz presented a list of ideas, one of which was the phrase “on the other hand.” Overstreet immediately paired it with “there’s a golden band,” sparking the song’s central theme of a man torn between temptation and commitment. Recorded by Randy Travis for his debut album Storms of Life, the song was first released in July 1985 but only reached number 67 on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart, a modest debut for Travis’ first single with Warner Bros. Nashville. However, the success of Travis’ follow-up single, 1982, which peaked at number six, prompted Warner executives, particularly Nick Hunter, to re-release On the Other Hand in April 1986. This time, it soared to number one in both the United States and Canada, becoming Travis’ first chart-topping hit. The song’s significance lies in its role as a cornerstone of Travis’ career and its embodiment of traditional country values during a period when the genre was flirting with pop influences. Its initial lukewarm reception gave way to widespread acclaim, cementing its place as a defining piece in Travis’ repertoire and the broader country music landscape.
Musical Style
On the Other Hand is a quintessential traditional country ballad, characterized by its simple yet evocative structure. The song follows a classic verse-chorus form, with a steady, mid-tempo rhythm that allows Travis’ warm, baritone voice to shine. The instrumentation is understated, featuring acoustic guitar, steel guitar, and subtle percussion, which create a tender, introspective mood. The steel guitar, in particular, adds a mournful twang that underscores the song’s emotional weight. The melody is memorable yet restrained, avoiding flashy flourishes to keep the focus on the storytelling. This simplicity, paired with Travis’ sincere delivery, amplifies the song’s authenticity, making it feel like a conversation with a close friend. The interplay between the melody and lyrics creates a push-and-pull effect, mirroring the protagonist’s internal conflict, which is the song’s emotional core.
Lyrics/Libretto
The lyrics of On the Other Hand tell the story of a man grappling with the allure of a new love while bound by his marriage, symbolized by the “golden band” on his finger. The recurring phrase “on the other hand” serves as a lyrical pivot, contrasting the temptation of passion with the duty of fidelity. Lines like “On one hand I could stay and be your loving man / But the reason I must go is on the other hand” capture the universal struggle between heart and conscience. The theme of moral choice resonates deeply, reflecting country music’s tradition of exploring life’s complexities through relatable narratives. The lyrics’ conversational tone, paired with vivid imagery like “a golden band / To remind me of someone who would not understand,” creates a poignant narrative that feels both personal and universal. The music complements this story, with the gentle rise and fall of the melody echoing the protagonist’s wavering resolve.
Performance History
Since its re-release in 1986, On the Other Hand has been a staple in Randy Travis’ live performances, often met with enthusiastic audience response for its emotional depth. The song’s chart success marked a turning point for Travis, establishing him as a leading voice in the neotraditional country movement. Over the years, it has been covered by artists like George Jones and Alan Jackson, further cementing its status as a country standard. Its inclusion in Travis’ debut album Storms of Life, which sold over three million copies, underscores its commercial and cultural impact. The song’s enduring popularity is evident in its frequent airplay on country radio and its inclusion in compilations of classic country hits. Its simplicity makes it accessible to performers, yet its emotional resonance ensures it remains a powerful piece in live settings.
Cultural Impact
On the Other Hand played a pivotal role in the neotraditional country revival of the 1980s, a movement that sought to return the genre to its roots amid the rise of country-pop crossovers. Its success helped pave the way for artists like Dwight Yoakam and George Strait, who championed authentic storytelling and traditional sounds. Beyond music, the song’s themes of fidelity and moral dilemma have made it a touchstone in discussions of love and commitment, resonating with listeners across generations. Its influence extends to popular culture, with references in TV shows and films that evoke rural American life. The song’s legacy is also tied to its role in shaping Randy Travis’ image as a sincere, relatable artist, whose music spoke to the heart of everyday struggles.
Legacy
The enduring importance of On the Other Hand lies in its ability to capture a universal human experience with honesty and grace. Decades after its release, it remains a beloved anthem for those navigating the complexities of love and duty. Its relevance today is evident in its continued presence in country music playlists and its influence on contemporary artists who draw inspiration from traditional country. The song’s legacy is also tied to its role in launching Randy Travis’ career, which helped redefine the genre for a new generation. For performers, it remains a challenging yet rewarding piece, demanding emotional authenticity to convey its depth. For audiences, it offers a timeless reminder of the power of choice and the weight of promises kept.
Conclusion
On the Other Hand is more than a country song—it’s a story of the human heart, told with a sincerity that transcends genre. Its journey from a overlooked single to a number-one hit mirrors its message of perseverance and truth. As I reflect on the song, I’m struck by how its simple melody and profound lyrics continue to move me, just as they did on those porch evenings long ago. I encourage readers to listen to Randy Travis’ original recording on Storms of Life or seek out a live performance, such as his 1986 Grand Ole Opry rendition, to experience its magic firsthand. Let this song remind you of the beauty in life’s tough choices and the music that helps us make sense of them
Video
Lyrics
On one hand I count the reasons
I could stay with you
And hold you close to me
All night long
So many lover’s games
I’d love to play with you
On that hand there’s no reason
Why it’s wrong
But on the other hand
There’s a golden band
To remind me of someone
Who would not understand
On one hand, I could stay (aah)
And be your lovin’ man
But the reason I must go
Is on the other hand
In your arms, I feel the passion
I thought had died
When I looked into your eyes
I found myself
And when I first kissed your lips
I felt so alive
I’ve got to hand it to you girl
You’re somethin’ else
But on the other hand
There’s a golden band
To remind me of someone
Who would not understand
On one hand, I could stay (aah)
And be your lovin’ man
But the reason I must go
Is on the other hand
Yeah the reason I must go
Is on the other hand