
He Was Only Supposed To Hold The Place
Jimmy Fortune did not enter the Statler Brothers as the next great chapter.
He entered as a temporary answer to a medical crisis. By late 1981, Lew DeWitt had been fighting Crohn’s disease for years, and the illness had worn him down badly enough that he stepped away for surgery and treatment. Both Jimmy Fortune’s official biography and the Country Music Hall of Fame describe Fortune first joining as a temporary replacement for DeWitt.
The Space He Walked Into Was Not Ordinary
That is what makes the handoff feel so heavy.
Lew was not just another member rotating out of a successful group. He was a founding Statler, the original tenor, and the writer of “Flowers on the Wall,” the song that helped define the group’s identity for the world. Replacing him was never going to feel like filling a routine vacancy. It meant stepping into a sound people already associated with the core of the group itself.
The First Night Already Carried The Weight
Following an audition in Nashville, Fortune played his first show with the Statlers on January 28, 1982, in Savannah, Georgia. That date matters because it marks the moment when “temporary” stopped being abstract and became a real human burden: a younger singer stepping onstage with a group whose shape had already been fixed in the public mind.
Lew Tried To Come Back
What makes the story linger is that the handoff did not become final all at once.
Lew did try to return in 1982. But the comeback did not hold. Sources differ slightly on the exact month, but they agree on the larger truth: his health would not let him reclaim the role for long, and the arrangement collapsed almost immediately. By that summer, Jimmy Fortune had become the permanent replacement.
The Group Kept Going — But Not Unchanged
That is the part worth keeping.
The Statler Brothers continued successfully, and Fortune would go on to write some of their biggest 1980s hits. But the group did not simply move forward as if nothing had happened. It moved on with Lew DeWitt’s absence still fresh inside it. The harmony survived. The success continued. But the original shape of the group had already been broken by illness before it was rebuilt in another form.
