“Toby Keith Once Honored Johnny Rodriguez By Singing “I Couldn’t Be Me Without You” This story is quite touching. In early 2020, while stuck in Mexico during the COVID-19 pandemic, Toby Keith found himself without a guitar. To keep playing music and soothe his soul, he bought an old guitar from a furniture store. In a simple, homemade video, Toby performed the song “I Couldn’t Be Me Without You”—written by Billy Joe Shaver and famously taken to #3 on the country charts by Johnny Rodriguez in 1976. Before he started singing, Toby shared: “Billy Joe Shaver wrote a little song, and Johnny Rodriguez sang the p— out of it.” With nothing but that old guitar, his raspy voice, and a plain backdrop, Toby conveyed a heartfelt sincerity. This wasn’t just a cover—it was a tribute. That moment has only grown more moving with time, as all three men connected to the song—Billy Joe Shaver (who passed away in October 2020), Toby Keith (February 5, 2024), and Johnny Rodriguez (May 9, 2025)—have now left us. One song, three men, and one seemingly small moment—now a timeless memory in the history of country music.

You know those songs that sneak up on you—quiet, humble, not flashy at all—but they hit you right in the chest? “I Couldn’t Be Me Without You” is exactly that kind of song. Written by the late Billy Joe Shaver, a true outlaw poet of country music, and made famous by Johnny Rodriguez in 1976, it’s the kind of tune that doesn’t just speak—it confesses.

At its heart, this song is simple but soul-deep. It’s a man laying his pride down, saying without hesitation: “You’re the reason I am who I am.” That’s the kind of vulnerability you don’t always hear in country these days—raw, tender, and unafraid to be honest. When Johnny sang it back in the ’70s, his smooth, heartfelt delivery made it soar all the way to #3 on the country charts. It became a quiet anthem for those who knew love was their backbone.

Fast forward to 2020: Toby Keith, stuck in Mexico during the pandemic, finds himself without a guitar (which for a country singer is like being without your voice). So, what does he do? He walks into a furniture store, buys a beat-up old guitar, and records a stripped-down version of this very song. No production, no polish—just Toby, a six-string, and a song that clearly meant the world to him.

And let me tell you, it worked. That performance wasn’t just a cover—it was a tribute. Toby’s deep, weathered voice gave the lyrics a new weight, a lived-in feel. You could hear the respect he had for both Johnny Rodriguez and Billy Joe Shaver in every note.

Now, with all three men—Billy Joe, Johnny, and Toby—having passed on, this little acoustic session feels like something more. It feels sacred. Like a piece of musical history quietly recorded on a borrowed guitar in a quiet moment, now echoing a much larger legacy.

Video